When is Typing Faster Than Handwriting?

Most elementary-age students struggle with typing. This doesn’t surprise me. They’ve been handwriting since kindergarten. They’re proud of their new cursive skills. It’s easy to grab and pencil and write. Typing, though requires setting up their posture, hand position, trying to remember where all those pesky keys are (why aren’t they just alphabetized? It’s a good point. Discuss that with students).

In third grade, I gather the students and we chat about it. Why do they have to learn to keyboard? It’s more than a skill they trot out for the keyboarding software and then forget. Discuss the idea of sharing ideas–the Gutenberg Press, when writing began with scrolls and rocks, why was it important to save ideas in perpetuity? Why is it important to students?

The discussion should come around to the idea that putting ideas in some sort of permanent fashion is important to the history of mankind. The question is how, and the ‘how’ that’s relevant to the students is a comparison of handwriting and keyboarding. Here’s where we go from there:

scientific method

Circle back on science in technology

  • Discuss whether students handwrite faster/slower than they type. Ask students to share thoughts on why their opinion is true. You are likely to get opinions on both sides of this discussion. If not, prod students with logic for both.
  • When it’s clear the class is divided on this subject (or not–that’s fine too), suggest running an experiment to see which is faster—handwriting or typing.
  • Circle back to science class and engage in a discussion on the Scientific Method. Develop a hypothesis for this class research, something like: Third grade students in Mr. X’s class can handwrite faster than they type (this is the most common opinion in my classes).
  • Have students hand-copy the typing quiz they took earlier in the trimester for 3 minutes.
  • Analyze the results: Compare their handwriting speed to their typing speed. I encourage an individual comparison as well as a class average comparison to help with understanding the conclusion.
  • Discuss results: Why do students think some students typed faster and others typed slower?  (In my classes, third graders typed approx. 10 wpm and handwrote approx. 15 wpm. Discussion was heated and enthusiastic on reasons. Especially valuable were the thoughts of those rare students who typed faster).
  • Students will offer lots of reasons for slower typing (they’re new to typing, don’t do it much in class, their hands got off on the keyboard). In truth, the logistics of typing make it the hands-down winner once key placement is secured. Fingers on a keyboard are significantly faster than the moving pencil.
  • One reason students suggest is that they don’t usually type from copy. Key in on this reason (quite valid, I think—don’t you?) and revise the experiment to have students type and handwrite from a prompt.
  • What is the final conclusion?
  • If possible, share results from 4-8th. What grade level do students consistently type faster than they handwrite? Why? Are students surprised by the answer?
  • Post a list on the wall of students who type faster than they handwrite. This surprises everyone.

I do this experiment in 3rd, 4th and 5th grade. Third, students on average handwrite faster. By 4th, the average is the same–students can type as fast as they handwrite. This surprises them and energizes them to work harder on their keyboarding. By 5th, most students type faster, though many didn’t expect that.

After this experiment, I see more students selecting keyboarding over handwriting, especially if an iPad is available rather than the cumbersome laptop or desktop. I also see them caring more about the skill of keyboarding as they realize it is their future. This has become an important tool in my keyboarding toolkit  that is fully as effective as practicing drills.

For more tricks like this, check out The Essential Guide to Keyboarding in 45 Minutes a Week.

Note: There are lots of examples of the scientific method and they all vary when talking about elementary grades. Talk to your science teacher and adapt this experiment to the one she uses.

Jacqui Murray is the editor of a K-6 technology curriculum, K-8 keyboard curriculum, creator of two technology training books for middle school and six ebooks on technology in education. She is the author of Building a Midshipman, the story of her daughter’s journey from high school to United States Naval Academy. She is webmaster for six blogs, an Amazon Vine Voice book reviewer, a columnist for Examiner.com, Editorial Review Board member for Journal for Computing Teachers, Cisco guest blog, Technology in Education featured blogger, IMS tech expert, and a bi-weekly contributor to Write Anything. Currently, she’s editing a thriller that should be out to publishers next summer. Contact Jacqui at her writing office or her tech lab, Ask a Tech Teacher.

Follow me

Categories: critical thinking, Keyboarding | Tags: , , | 6 Comments

Post navigation

6 thoughts on “When is Typing Faster Than Handwriting?

  1. I’m sharing this comment I got on another arm of my PLN. Sounds like an interesting program:

    Hi Jacqui…I teach typing using Keyboard Classroom software (www.keyboardclassroom.com). The program has 5 easy levels that introduces all the letters, combinations and sentences needed to learn how to touch type correctly. Students practice 15 minutes a day and at around 6 months they will have MASTERED the program and will be proficient typists! Their speed will increase as they start to type their homework, papers etc. We have been successfully using this program for the past 23 years! I would love to send you a copy of my program to compare to the one you suggested. I think it’s a more efficient way of teaching typing by far!”

  2. Pingback: Why Keyboarding Should NOT be Dead | Ask a Tech Teacher

  3. Pingback: Handwriting vs. Keyboarding–from a Student’s Perspective | Ask a Tech Teacher

  4. Pingback: Handwriting vs. Keyboarding–from a Student’s Perspective « Ask a Tech Teacher

  5. Jacqui,
    I really enjoy your blog posts. They hit home often with what is happening in the classroom with the students I service!
    This was a great post gathering evidences from typical students. From an OT and ATP stand point we typically work at increasing students with special needs ability to keyboard, typically easier for them to produce, edit and multi-task than the manual process. We compare their handwriting vs. keyboarding to get them to speed so that the word processing is not frustrating if using as a compensatory method of output. It is especially interesting to review your information from a typical student stand point, not one that I can have evidence from!

    Thank you again for your post and your continual supply of thoughtful, practical classroom information!!
    Carol Leynse Harpold, MS AdEd, OTR/L, ATP
    OT’s with Apps. com

    • Thanks, Carol. I learn to teach by listening to my students. This was one of those cases. I think all of us enjoyed this experiment.

      I’m so glad to hear you encourage keyboarding for those students who struggle with handwriting. There are still teachers who insist students struggle through a skill that is close to impossible for them (for a variety of reasons)–or if not impossible, much less frustrating done a different way. I think ‘differentiation’ should extend to this level of communication.

What do you think? Leave a comment and I'll reply.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Website Powered by WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: